Trying to decide between Greenville’s Upstate energy and Savannah’s coastal charm? If you are comparing these two Southern metros, the question usually comes down to what your monthly budget looks like once housing, transportation, utilities, and taxes are in the mix. The good news is you can get to a clear answer with a few live sources and simple calculations.
Below, you will learn how to compare the biggest cost drivers, where to find current numbers, and what tradeoffs matter most for daily life. Use the templates to plug in your own figures, then shortlist neighborhoods that fit your budget and lifestyle. Let’s dive in.
Quick snapshot: what usually drives cost
- Housing tends to be the largest swing. Your choice of neighborhood can change the bottom line more than city averages.
- Insurance and flood risk are a bigger factor near Savannah’s waterways. Greenville’s inland setting often means less exposure to flood-related coverage.
- Utilities at the state level are broadly comparable. Your HVAC usage and home efficiency will matter more than small rate differences.
- Both metros are car dependent for most households, with limited but useful transit in core areas.
- State and local taxes differ. Property tax structures and state income tax rules can change your take-home number.
Housing: how to compare monthly costs
Start with your likely purchase price or rent, then layer in recurring ownership or rental costs. Always label whether you are looking at city proper or metro numbers. Market stats change monthly, so pull current figures before you calculate.
Where to find live housing benchmarks
- Median sale prices and rent levels: check well-known market data portals and local MLS reports for current city or metro figures.
- Inventory and days on market: use local MLS summaries to gauge leverage for buyers or sellers.
Ownership cost checklist
- Mortgage payment template
- Principal and interest: loan amount, interest rate, and term drive this number. Use a standard mortgage calculator to compute monthly principal and interest.
- Private mortgage insurance: add if your down payment is below 20 percent.
- Homeowners insurance: coastal properties near Savannah may need wind and flood riders that raise premiums. Budget a realistic annual number and divide by 12.
- Property taxes
- Effective tax rate varies by county and property type. For Greenville-area homes, review rates through the Greenville County Assessor. For Savannah-area homes, check the Chatham County Board of Assessors.
- Basic formula: (assessed value × local millage rate) ÷ 12. Confirm assessment methods and exemptions before you estimate.
- Flood and hazard insurance
- For low-lying or waterfront homes near Savannah, verify flood zones and elevation using the FEMA Flood Map Service Center. If flood insurance is required or recommended, get quotes before you finalize a budget.
- HOA and condo fees
- Many newer subdivisions and in-town condos carry monthly or quarterly fees. Ask for the current budget and special assessments.
Example: buyer template you can plug in
Buyer with a target price
- Purchase price: your target number
- Down payment: percent you plan to put down
- Loan amount and rate: monthly principal and interest from a mortgage calculator
- Property tax: use county assessor rates, then divide by 12
- Homeowners insurance: add annual premium divided by 12; include flood if applicable
- HOA or condo fees: monthly range based on property
- Utilities: estimate electric, water, sewer, gas, trash, and internet based on provider tariffs
- Total monthly housing: sum of the above
Tip: Run this template for both Greenville and Savannah neighborhoods you are considering. Compare totals rather than focusing only on the purchase price.
Renting: core items to include
- Monthly rent for your preferred size and location
- Utilities and internet, plus any parking fees
- Renters insurance
- Commuting cost based on your likely route and gas prices
Renter tradeoff example
- Downtown 2-bedroom: higher rent, lower transportation cost, more walkability
- Suburban 3-bedroom: lower rent per square foot, higher transportation cost, more space
Utilities and internet: what changes the bill
Electricity, water, and internet are mostly about usage and provider options. State averages can help you compare baselines, then local tariffs fill in the details.
- Electricity: check South Carolina and Georgia statewide trends using the EIA’s residential electricity prices. Summer cooling and humidity can be intense in both metros, with coastal homes around Savannah often running dehumidification more frequently.
- Natural gas: review local provider rate schedules and monthly service charges. Some neighborhoods rely on electric-only HVAC.
- Water, sewer, and trash: municipalities set base fees plus usage tiers. Ask for recent bills from the seller or property manager when possible.
- Internet: fiber and high-speed cable vary by neighborhood. Availability affects price, speed, and remote work quality.
Simple monthly estimate template
- Electric: kWh used × price per kWh
- Water and sewer: base fee + usage
- Internet: plan price based on speed and provider
- Add any fixed trash or recycling fees
Transportation and commute: car-first with pockets of transit
Most households in both metros drive to work. Your commute distance, traffic patterns, and parking costs often outweigh small differences in gas prices.
- Gas prices: get current regional averages on AAA Gas Prices.
- Commute times: both cities see peak traffic near major corridors. Drive your route during rush hour to validate real times.
- Public transit: Savannah’s network is run by Chatham Area Transit. Greenville’s city bus service is Greenlink. If you plan to rely on transit, shortlist homes near frequent routes.
- Airports: frequent travelers should compare routes from Greenville-Spartanburg International and Savannah/Hilton Head International. Flight frequency can influence time and cost.
Commute cost template
- Monthly miles: round-trip miles × workdays per month
- Fuel: monthly miles ÷ vehicle mpg × current price per gallon
- Parking and tolls: add any monthly fees
Day-to-day expenses: groceries, dining, healthcare, childcare
Groceries and dining
- Price differences are usually modest at the metro level. Store choice and shopping habits will influence your basket more than city averages.
- Local seafood access can affect menu pricing around Savannah, while national chains keep many staples similar in both places.
Healthcare
- Both metros have major health systems. Compare plan networks, copays, and premiums based on your employer or marketplace plan. Facility proximity can save time and money.
Childcare
- Daycare and after-school programs vary by provider and waitlist. Request current rates from centers near your target neighborhoods and compare by hours covered.
Taxes that affect your take-home
- State income tax: review brackets and deductions for each state. See the South Carolina Department of Revenue and the Georgia Department of Revenue for current details.
- Sales tax: add state plus local county or city rates for an accurate picture.
- Property tax: confirm effective rates and exemptions on county assessor pages before you finalize your budget.
Neighborhood shortlists and tradeoffs
Greenville area ideas
- Downtown and West End: walkable core with dining and entertainment, higher price per square foot.
- North Main and Overbrook: established residential pockets close to downtown, mix of older homes.
- Augusta Road: established neighborhoods with convenient access to services.
- Taylors, Simpsonville, and Mauldin: suburban choices with newer subdivisions and varied HOA amenities.
Savannah area ideas
- Historic District, Thomas Square, and Ardsley Park: historic, walkable areas with a mix of housing types.
- Midtown: residential pockets with in-town access.
- Pooler: rapidly growing suburb near the airport with newer construction.
- Southside Chatham County and Isle of Hope: suburban and waterfront options, verify flood zones when near waterways.
Match your list to your routine
- If you want a short commute and less driving, focus on in-town addresses near your workplace or transit routes.
- If you want more space and a yard, compare suburban options and add realistic transportation and time costs to your budget.
Build your budget: a simple step-by-step
- Pull current home prices or rents for your target neighborhoods.
- Run a mortgage or rent calculation with taxes, insurance, and HOA fees included. Verify property taxes with the Greenville County Assessor or the Chatham County Board of Assessors.
- Check flood zones and get insurance quotes early using the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.
- Estimate utilities using provider tariffs and your home size. Confirm average bills when possible.
- Price your commute using AAA Gas Prices and trial runs at rush hour; add parking.
- Account for state taxes using the South Carolina Department of Revenue or the Georgia Department of Revenue.
- Compare totals for two to three neighborhoods in each metro, then shortlist homes that fit both budget and lifestyle.
Ready for local guidance and on-the-ground numbers? Reach out to the The Trisha Cook Team for neighborhood-level insights, live market data, and a tailored budget plan that fits how you live.
FAQs
What is the biggest cost difference between Greenville and Savannah?
- Housing and insurance usually drive the delta, with coastal flood and wind coverage near Savannah adding cost in some areas, while Greenville’s inland locations often avoid those premiums.
How do I estimate property taxes in each city?
Do I need flood insurance in Savannah?
- It depends on the property’s flood zone and elevation; check the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and get quotes from your insurer before you make an offer.
Are utilities higher in Greenville or Savannah?
- State averages for electric rates are comparable, but actual bills vary by home efficiency and HVAC use; verify your estimate using the EIA’s residential electricity prices and local tariffs.
Can I rely on public transit instead of a car?
How do state taxes affect my take-home pay?